This article analyzes the commissions efforts to address the. In 2007, quebecs bouchard taylor commission investigated the issue of reasonable accommodation of minorities in the province, hearing from experts, individuals and organizations on identity. In 2008, gerard bouchard and charles taylor released an important report as co chairs of the consultation commission on accommodation practices related. We present the narrativeof this report and the recommendations that flow from it to the president of the united states, the united states congress, and the. The issue was published just as public hearings of the bouchard taylor commission on state secularism, immigrant integation and relations between minorities and the frenchspeaking. Lets move on, says quebec accommodation commission cbc news.
Religion, culture, and the stateaddresses reasonable accommodation from legal, political, and anthropological perspectives, with the contributors using the 2008 bouchard taylor report as their point of departure to contextualize the english and french canadian experiences of multiculturalism and diversity. Quebecs bouchard taylor commission investigated the issue of reasonable accommodation of. Faculty of graduate and postdoctoral studies in partial fulfillment of the requirements. This has created the expectation among many members of immigrant communities. Study on the conditions of claims for damages in case of.
Quebec nationalism and the production of difference. In 2008, gerard bouchard and charles taylor released an important report as cochairs of the consultation commission on accommodation practices related. The commission was set up by the quebec government in response to public discontent concerning reasonable accommodation of religious and cultural practices. Infoman commission bouchard taylor engsubs youtube. Commission on social determinants of health final report. A crisis of perception 17 the commission investigates two researchers mandated by the commission reconstructed the facts based on a sampling of 21 cases among those that received the broadest media coverage by relying on the documentation available and questioning interveners and witnesses. Taylor staff assistant yoel tobin counsel emily landis walker. Commission on social determinants of health final report the commission calls for closing the health gap in a generation social justice is a matter of life and death. Revelations from the 2007 bouchard taylor commission on reasonable accommodation by. It affects the way people live, their consequent chance of illness, and their risk of premature death. Of the full report general introduction the commission the commission s mandate, investigation, and orientations is there an accomodation crisis. Quebec academics reasonable accommodations report an oil slick that just keeps growing the bouchard taylor report, released in 2008, was supposed to put an end to quebecs.
Quebec hearings on reasonable accommodation of minorities begin next month. Report of the bouchard taylor commission on reasonable accommodation of minorities. The foundations of collective life in quebec are not in a critical situation, said the bouchard taylor commission, in its final report on the state of socalled reasonable accommodation of. In 2008, gerard bouchard and charles taylor released an important report as cochairs of the consultation commission on accommodation practices related to cultural differences. Premier jean charest, citing several instances of unreasonable accommodation, advised the lieutenant governor of quebec to appoint a twoman commission in february 2007, to investigate the issue of reasonable accommodation, and report back by 31 march 2008. Religion, culture, and the state reflections on the.
This paper follows a path through a number of events during this period in order to tease out the. Commission heard quebecs ageold language debate which dominated the second day of the bouchard taylor hearings on religious accommodation. A few months later, in may of 2008, its report was disclosed. The commission was set up by the quebec government in response to public discontent concerning reasonable accommodation. We watch in wonder as life expectancy and good health continue.
Implications of religious diversity for public policies from a human rights perspective. When two highly regarded quebec intellectuals, gerard bouchard and charles taylor, released their longawaited report in late may on reasonable accommodation of the provinces ethnic and religious minorities, it was hard to imagine that all. Lets move on, says quebec accommodation commission cbc. Via bolognese 156 villa salviati 509 firenze italy. Any unauthorized access or tentative constitutes an illegal act which will be reported to the authorities and which is liable to recourse in justice. While the full report of the taylor commission is too long to reproduce here, this electronic briefing book provides excerpted passages from eight key documents, substantial portions of which were previously unavailable in the censored versions of the report released in 1977 and 1986. The commission, which launched its hearings in gatineau, heard from dozens of people who stressed the primacy of french in quebecs value system.
City of montreal this is a private system under monitoring. Commission et son rapport dans lorbite generale des. Religious accommodation and human rights in quebec1 jocelyn maclure2 1 i wish to thank the participants to the workshop religious diversity and public policies. Pdf quebec nationalism and the production of difference. In the spring of 2007, after several months of public controversy about reasonable accommodation, integration policies and ethnoreligious minorities, the bouchard taylor commission was established. Exclusion of indigenous peoples and issues in the commission s final report 77 chapter 6.
This paper offers theoretical reflections on the modern nationstate, the poltical. Study on the conditions of claims for damages in case of infringement of ec competition rules comparative report prepared by denis waelbroeck, donald slater and gil evenshoshan. Canada, appointed the bouchardtaylor commission to investigate. Building the future a time for reconciliation pucp. Submssion to the bouchardtaylor commission, september. The bouchardtaylor report on cultural and religious.
Submission to the bouchard taylor commission official multiculturalism policy one of the principal contributing factors that has caused confusion and misunderstanding has been the introduction of multiculturalism policy by the federal government in the 1970s. This paper takes as its point of departure the submissions made by various by members. He examines the contexts and upshots of frances 2003 stasi commission and concludes that the differences in its recommendations from those of the bouchard taylor commission reflected contradictions between the two societies interpretations of liberalism. Extract chapter 7 some reflections on the bouchardtaylor commission the consultation commission on accommodation practices related to cultural differences was created in february 2007 following a series of incidents that received a great deal of attention in the media and that the commission s report itself described as related to increasing identity anxiety between. But some expressed concern about the public debate over.
Report of the bouchardtaylor commission on reasonable. Religion, culture, and the state addresses reasonable accommodation from legal, political, and anthropological perspectives, with the contributors using the 2008 bouchard taylor report as their point of departure to contextualize the english and french canadian experiences of multiculturalism and diversity. Central to debates playing out about religious diversity and multiculturalism is the deployment of the rhetoric of the protection of women and egalite hommefemme. For those following politics in quebec, the 20072008 period was an opportune time to conduct research on the dynamics of race and national identity. Infoman commission bouchard taylor engsubs anglo montreal. Gada mahrouse, in her critique of the bouchardtaylor commission, also.
251 80 496 1599 223 97 991 1237 601 1211 271 353 406 656 982 1206 502 629 67 352 75 998 1041 192 685 803 956 1252 206 1236 1121 317 1529 390 1269 1061 840 952 589 864